New Plan
hen the US Forest Service last rewrote the rules for managing the Tongass National Forest in 1997, federal law required those rules to be revised every fifteen years. Nearly thirty years later, the agency is finally getting around to writing a new plan, a delay it now concedes in its own paperwork, describing the current effort as an update to “the current plan, adopted in 1997.”
The document has been amended twice since it was initially adopted, most substantially in 2016, but it has never had a true rewrite. That 2016 amendment is still the operative rulebook today. It directed the agency to supply 45 million board feet of timber from the Tongass annually, according to Tessa Axelson, executive director of the Alaska Forest Association, a target she says the Forest Service has never come close to hitting.
The Forest Service opened the current revision process in 2023, formally launched scoping in February 2026, and, after a schedule that has already slipped once, now expects to release a full draft sometime in early 2027.
Nathan Newcomer, Tongass campaigner with the Southeast Alaska Conservation Council, arrives at the same conclusion from the opposite direction. He points to the pace of old-growth logging, not timber shortfalls, as the plan’s central failure. Venables and Newcomer disagree on almost everything about what a new plan should do, but both call the current one overdue.
Venables has also pushed the Forest Service to adopt something like Southeast Conference’s own annual “Southeast by the Numbers” report, a sector-by-sector accounting of the regional economy, applied to the Tongass itself. “You really can’t manage well what you’re not measuring,” he says.
lifeofriley | Adobe Stock
Venables sees that as part of a longer pattern. “The last quarter century, the Tongass has only been managed by presidential decree,” he says. “Until there’s a legislative directive, I think the forest will continue to be managed by presidential administrative orders. That’s just what’s happened over the last twenty-some odd years, and it’s not surprising that that’s what’s driving this, because every administration comes in and does the same thing.”
The industry has felt this firsthand. Axelson points to 2021, when then-US Secretary of Agriculture Tom Vilsack halted old-growth harvest in the Tongass through what’s become known as the Southeast Alaska Sustainability Strategy, an action she calls “an illegal press release.” It left just 5 million board feet for micro-operators and cultural uses, a fraction of the 2016 amendment’s 45 million board foot annual target. That’s her characterization, not a court finding.
The revision of the plan is also unfolding alongside a separate federal effort to rescind the 2001 Roadless Rule nationwide, which would restore the Tongass’s exemption from a rule that bars road construction and logging in roadless areas, or about 9.3 of its 16.7 million acres. Another effort is aimed at a March 2026 ruling from US District Judge Sharon Gleason that found that timber volume targets in the 2016 plan are aspirational goals rather than legally binding commitments the Forest Service must meet.
These policies inspired the Tongass Timber Reform Act of 1990, which modified the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act and revisited forest management, forest lands protection, and long-term timber sale contracts in Southeast, among other changes. The Alaska Pulp Corporation mill in Sitka and the Ketchikan Pulp Corporation mill at Ward Cove were out of business within three and seven years, respectively, citing uneconomic conditions under the new law.
The ‘80s are long past, and the most the industry might expect from the Forest Service is delivering on the promise of 45 million board feet.
As of last February, the Forest Service was telling the public to expect a draft plan and environmental impact statement this fall. That timeline has moved a bit. Paul Robbins Jr., the Tongass’ public affairs and partnerships staff officer, says that the schedule has shifted as the agency has “refined the work to be done, streamlined public engagement plans, adjusted to staffing changes, and identified new issues.” The current target is early 2027, and the release of the draft plan would trigger a ninety-day comment period. A target is not a promise, though.
Neither Venables nor Newcomer seems surprised. Venables points out that the agency has moved at very different speeds before: Alaska’s original inclusion in the national Roadless Rule took only months under the Clinton administration, while the 2021 Southeast Alaska Sustainability Strategy was later shelved just as abruptly. “There’s some that feel that this is a rushed process, there’s some that feel like this is dragging on,” he says. “I don’t know. It’s hard to pace the government.”
She also pushes back on the idea that the industry looks anything like the “industrial corporate complex of logging” that critics sometimes describe. “All of our members are small businesses,” she says, “many of which are multi-generational family businesses.” What they need, she says, is durable, predictable supply. “[Alaska Forest Association] has been requesting durable supply prior to the issuance of the orders,” she says.
On young growth as a substitute for old growth, Axelson says the two aren’t interchangeable. She points to a specific example: soundboards for Steinway & Sons pianos are made from old-growth Sitka spruce harvested in the Tongass, and young growth lacks the characteristics to replace it. Southeast also has little large-scale manufacturing capacity, she says, and shipping young-growth logs to the Lower 48 is expensive.
For Alaska Forest Association, the uncertainty doesn’t start after the draft plan comes out. “Uncertainty existed before the process began,” Axelson says. Until the agency actually delivers volume, she says her members can’t make long-term decisions about investment, equipment, or hiring. “The industry cannot survive on just-in-time timber sales.”
Like Southeast Conference, Alaska Forest Association put its own alternative in front of the Forest Service. Axelson points to what the association calls its Seven Generations Alternative, which lays out the industry’s volume needs alongside a proposed 250-year timber rotation. That number lands almost exactly on the 150- to 250-year horizon that Venables has separately pushed through the Tongass Collaborative, the same stakeholder group that’s drafting its own “citizens’ alternative” for the agency to consider. For two organizations with very different constituencies, timber operators on one side, the region’s broader economy on the other, that’s a notable point of convergence.
What’s riding on the draft is more than a schedule. It’s whether mills in Ketchikan and Craig get a supply number they can plan around, which is what Axelson says her members need most. It’s whether the salmon streams and old-growth stands that Newcomer and tribes involved in this process are watching remain protected. It’s whether the small operators cutting beach logs and firewood, the ones nobody’s quoting in Federal Register notices, get any say in it at all.
The plan adopted in 1997 was supposed to answer those questions within fifteen years. Whatever finally arrives in 2027 will have to answer for the thirty it took to get there.