Circular Logic: Why Roundabouts?

A

ccording to the Alaska Department of Transportation & Public Facilities (DOT&PF), in 2000 Alaska didn’t have any roundabouts, but as of early last year the state had more than thirty-six, and that number continues to grow. Roundabouts are commonly included in new road construction, and many intersections across the state have been renovated to integrate roundabout designs. DOT&PF states: “The trend in Alaska mirrors the trend across the United States for a simple reason: [roundabouts] are much safer than a traditional signalized or four-way-stop intersection.”

DOT&PF explains three primary reasons that roundabouts are safer: there are fewer collision points, fewer serious injury crashes, and increased safety for pedestrians.

There are thirty-two possible “collision points” in a traditional four-way intersection, as vehicles cross traffic while turning left, turn right on a red light, speed up to make the intersection before a light change, or engage in other typical intersection behaviors; however, in a roundabout there are only eight points of collision, four where vehicles enter the roundabout and four where vehicles exit.

When crashes do happen, they are less likely to result in serious injury or death. This is in part because a roundabout configuration almost eliminates the possibility of head-on and T-bone crashes. Vehicles in the roundabout are also traveling at a slower speed, which reduces the severity of the consequences of a crash.

And because vehicles move slower within and when entering and exiting the roundabout, both drivers and pedestrians have a better chance to react to avoid collisions.

DOT&PF reports that, according to national studies, intersections converted from a traditional configuration to a roundabout experience a 90 percent reduction in fatalities, a 75 percent reduction in injuries, and a 35 percent reduction in crashes overall. “We have seen similar results at roundabouts in Alaska,” the department states. “In the ten years since roundabouts were installed at an intersection in North Pole, there have been zero injury crashes and a 68 percent reduction in crashes overall.”

Roundabouts have also been shown to reduce congestion, reduce fuel usage and pollution, and lower the long-term costs of maintaining an intersection.

Rendering of the proposed Danby-Wembley roundabout in Fairbanks slated for construction this summer.

© R&M

Rendering of the proposed Danby-Wembley roundabout in Fairbanks slated for construction this summer.
Rendering of the proposed Danby-Wembley roundabout in Fairbanks slated for construction this summer.

© R&M

Because of all of these benefits, DOT&PF now has a “Roundabout First” policy, meaning “designers must provide a written justification of any decision to install a traffic signal instead of a single-lane roundabout. Roundabouts are not appropriate for every intersection, but under the right circumstances, they can save lives, reduce injury, and save money.”

For more information, including tips for navigating a roundabout, visit dot.alaska.gov/stwddes/dcstraffic/roundabouts.shtml.